Sometime in December of 2019, someone in China purchased a live bat for their dinner, a vendor killed it, put it in a bag and then one of those people got sick.
No one even knew what kind of illness it was yet. Just a weird case of pneumonia. Soon there were three people with a similar illness. Dr Li Wenliang, one of the doctors who noticed the very first cases of this weird pneumonia, was arrested after getting a message out on social media to some of his university colleagues. China at the time did not want anyone to know.
Even so, the Chinese Government did notify the World Health Organization about this strange illness on December 31 2019.
Dr Gabriel Leung, a top expert on coronaviruses, said in an interview that he first heard rumours about a possible new type of pneumonia back in December. Others say it’s possible that there were cases as far back as November 2019, but that seems to be just a rumour for now.
The very next day, New Years Day, The World Health Organization received another report from China about the new illness and there were dozens of new cases.
An investigation found that two-thirds of the first patients were vendors at the Huanan Seafood market. It was permanently closed on January 1, 2020. At the time, they thought the people who were sick contracted it from an animal and it was not contagious between humans.
The first person to die was on January 11, 2020, and we don’t even know that person’s name. Ten days later, there were 17 people dead. By January 2o, there were over 500 cases in China and as it turns out, COVID-19 was super contagious.
Fast forward to March 1, 2020 and China reports just over 80,000 cases of COVID-19.
Two weeks later, they are holding at around 80,000.
Just 4 days after that, Thursday March 19, China makes the claim that they have seen no new cases and they have beaten COVID-19. The Chinese Government announces they are heading back to work and re-opening tourist attractions.
But check out this graph. The numbers went up steadily for months from December to February, then they start dropping and suddenly spike at 15,000 new cases in a single day and then just as suddenly, the numbers take a nosedive. Very odd don’t you agree?
The Chinese laid the hammer down and put Wuhan City into a lockdown back in January. Within a day or so, they announced new lockdowns across the country, closed airports, and halted travel.
China was keeping this under wraps as much as possible and telling the world that it wasn’t too bad and not to worry, they had it all under control. They were building 2 special new hospitals in just a couple of days and everything would be fine.
However, pictures and stories were leaking out on social media that painted a very different picture. China had arrested people, including Dr Li Wenliang who first rang the alarm. Another doctor in Wuhan, Dr Ai Fen, was reprimanded for sending a picture of a test result to her colleague back in December.
2 filmmakers in Wuhan City documented life inside the lockdown for 50 days and sent their documentary to the BBC, who aired it and posted it to youtube. That doc, shows that a single hospital in Wuhan had 200 COVID-19 patients back in late January. At that same hospital, over 200 health care workers had contracted the virus. That’s a single hospital. One. Before anything ever happened, there were and still are 20 hospitals in Wuhan. Let’s pretend they each treated 200 patients with the new SARS-like coronavirus. That’s 4000.
In January. If we look back at the graph, China officially reported around 10,000 cases for the whole country that day. The country was already locked down entirely and 2 new hospitals were being built. One hospital had 1400 medical staff and the second had 1600 beds. In total, 16 temporary hospitals were set up in Wuhan alone that each had the capacity for close to 1000 patients at a time.
In March, Dr Ai Fen gave an interview to Renwu, the Chinese version of People Magazine. In that interview she stated that in preparation for a visit from the Chinese President, many patients were simply discharged, sick or not, to make it look like there were fewer people suffering from COVID-19 than there really were.
China has kicked out journalists and inside the locked-down areas, things were wild. When government officials visited locked-down areas to brag about the success and make a big show of delivering food and supplies, residents opened their windows and yelled “Fake! Fake! It’s all Fake!”
Is it all fake? Did China lie about their numbers of COVID-19 cases and then lie about having stopped the spread of the virus?
Well, we know that only about 20% of COVID-19 patients require hospital care.
We also know from the BBC documentary filmed inside the lockdown area of Wuhan, that there were people reaching out online to each other and anti-viral drugs were being delivered to patients all over the city who could not get into hospitals. Let’s say because we saw that video and now we believe that many people were sick and were not admitted to hospitals.
China has a total of 33,000 hospitals not counting any of the temporary hospitals set up just for COVID-19 patients. Let’s just say each hospital in china only admitted 200 people with COVID-19. My reasoning is that because China suddenly built 16 temporary hospitals in Hubei Province. They didn’t do that for no reason. That means 6 million 6 hundred thousand people were hospitalized BEFORE we count the patients who went to temporary hospitals.
That sounds crazy. Let’s pretend each hospital in China admitted only 50 patients with coronavirus over the course of the epidemic. That’s roughly 16 patients per month from January to March. Why would they would need 16 extra hospitals in that case, is beyond me, but whatever. I’m not psychic. I don’t know what they were thinking.
Let’s say that each temporary hospital treated just 1000 patients each. Even though we know some had higher capacity and not every patient stayed for a whole month. More likely, they stayed 2 weeks each or less and we should double the number, but we won’t worry about that for now.
That means there were 25,600 patients with COVID-19 to add to the previous number of 1,650,000. So – our ultra-conservative number of COVID-19 patients who were hospitalized is 1,675,600.00. That represents 20% of the total number of cases of COVID-19 in China, which they say is 81,054. You tell me? Is China lying?
commentary, coronavirus, culture, current events, health, India, life, opinion, research
India Keeps COVID-19 Numbers Low
In COVID-19, Epidemic, Flatten The Curve, Social Distancing, Uncategorized, World Health on March 22, 2020 at 12:22 pmIndia continues to report only a small number of COVID-19 cases. Interesting because the population of India is over 1.3 billion. Has anyone ever seen a picture from anywhere in India that didn’t show huge crowds of people? Their population alone dictates that their numbers should be a lot higher.
Would you be shocked to learn India is performing fewer COVID-19 tests than any other country in Asia, if not the entire world?
India’s policy has been only to test travellers who have visited COVID-19 affected countries. If a patient is ill with coronavirus symptoms, as long as they hadn’t been outside the country in the previous few weeks, it is still only considered a “suspect case”. Even in cases where a patient is on a ventilator, and on their deathbed, they are not isolated and there are no special protocols. Doctors are losing it.
People who have been exposed to COVID-19 and have not presented symptoms are having their hands stamped with a government seal indicating that they are under quarantine. Personally, I don’t think it’s really doing anything other than freaking people out.
India’s attitude seems to be No Test = No Covid-19.
The Government of India website does have information on how to slow the spread of the virus, but it’s all quite odd.
Then there is also this video with a cheerful little theme song, put out on youtube by the Government of India.
Even with the Government of India posting such sobering <insert eyeroll here> information online, citizens at large are responding to the outbreak in a variety of ways. On one hand, you still have people sharing non-sensical cures and preventions like garlic water or hosting cow urine drinking events.
Thank whatever God you want for a team of PHD Students out of India who have been using actual science to look for solutions. They created a brand new and less invasive test for the COVID-19 virus, that is better, cheaper and faster than the current one.
On Thursday, March 19, Prime Minister Narendra Modi announced a curfew starting at 7 am Sunday, March 22. Problem; it ends at 9 pm the same day.
Delhi, has a slightly longer curfew that will start Monday, March 23 and last until March 31.
Even so, the Government is handing out meals to large groups of people. So much for social distancing.
While some areas have been locked down, others have not. The lockdowns are only in place for one week. The Indian Government has cancelled all visas. Existing visas have all been suspended. Yet, according to a Union Home Ministry notification, those visas have been extended. That mixed message has led to foreigners being kicked out of their accommodations and unable to leave the country.
Simultaneously, India is welcoming planeloads of ex-pats back into the country from places like Italy.
Some, (I would guess many) in India are hoping that Modi’s Janata Curfew is just a trial run for a national lockdown to at least try and slow the spread the COVID-19 a little bit. Like something. Please.
As the rest of the world reacts to COVID-19 and the number of cases climbs day after day, many countries have closed borders and imposed various self-quarantine and social distancing rules. Everyone is looking hopefully at China since they made the claim that they have defeated COVID-19 after laying the hammer down.
Then we all shift our gaze to Italy and Spain allowing us a glimpse into our own futures. India should peer into that same crystal ball.
UPDATE March 24, 2020
India has announced a sudden and total lockdown of the entire country. President Modi said in a press conference today “If we are not able to manage this pandemic in the next 21 days, the country and your family will be setback by 21 years”. Only the very essential businesses will remain open and interstate transit is suspended.